- π¬π§United Kingdom catch
While there is no explicit plan yet, I think this is a more accurate issue title for what we'd like to happen.
- π«π·France andypost
LB still doesn't support form modes, so the way remains π Move Field Layout data model and API directly into \Drupal\Core\Entity\EntityDisplayBase Needs work
- π©π°Denmark ressa Copenhagen
Should we warn users that the module should probably not be used? I have created π Inform users that Field Layout is deprecated Active .
- π©πͺGermany rkoller NΓΌrnberg, Germany
In today's Usability Meeting π Drupal Usability Meeting 2024-02-09 Needs work we've discussed β¨ Improve the manage form display page by untwining field widgets that belong to the main content and sidebar Active outlining an underlaying problem which is relevant for this issue as well as for the Field Layout contrib module. The issue illustrates that things are already problematic without Field Layout being installed and you only have an
enabled
anddisabled
section on theManage form display
page. But with Field Layout set to for example a two column layout the problem gets worse. We've agreed on postponing β¨ Improve the manage form display page by untwining field widgets that belong to the main content and sidebar Active on this issue and bring it on everyone's radar. - ππΊHungary GΓ‘bor Hojtsy Hungary
@andypost highlighted that this has a product manager review tag. While there is a page building initiative being bootstrapped which will shine a lot more light on layout building that we did in recent years, I doubt that changing how forms are laid out will be a priority of that initiative either anytime soon. So my feeling is this issue will keep lingering here like it did throughout Drupal 9 and 10. If we want a "clean solution" we can deprecate and move it out to contrib like other core modules. Ideally it would be folded into layout builder, but that clearly did not happen in years.
- Status changed to Active
3 months ago 7:56am 12 August 2024 - π³πΏNew Zealand quietone
In an effort to get this moving I am setting the status to active. There is discussion here on a) moving it to contrib and b) to copy all the useful bits to core. The latter being in #8 and the child issue. The latest comment supports "If we want a "clean solution" we can deprecate and move it out to contrib like other core modules."
I would prefer the clean solution which is to deprecate and move to contrib and in Slack catch said the same. Shall we pursue that?
- π¬π§United Kingdom catch
π Move Field Layout data model and API directly into \Drupal\Core\Entity\EntityDisplayBase Needs work is a complete re-implementation of what field_layout tried to do, so I don't think we are really gaining anything by keeping it in core until that's done - the only reason to do so would be to provide an 'upgrade path' for sites using the experimental module, but we don't even know if that will be the case. So I think it's clearer if we move the module to contrib, on the basis some sites might be using it and we don't want to them to be left in a complete dead-end. It's been several years since field_layout was abandoned and keeping it in core isn't helping us replace it.
- π¬π§United Kingdom catch
Removing the 'needs release manager review' tag too given +1s from both me and @quietone.