Missing column headings in Revisions list

Rebased the MR.

We are using this patch and editors found it an improvement of the diff screen - I note there hasn't been much discussion on this since #11 so not setting to RTBC, although I can say I have one client happy using this approach.

Patch containing the current state of the merge request.

Sorry, ignore the patch in #22. This is the correct patch containing the current state of the merge request.

@miro_dietiker: Perhaps the column labels should be "Compare revision A" and "Compare revision B" or "Compare from" and "Compare to".

The question of the compare button on long forms is addressed in ✨ Add "compare revisions" button on top for long form. Needs review .

PHPStan is failing.

Rebased. phpstan passes.

+1 to the latest patch.

I'm not a huge fan of these column headings, and as stated already in the comments the A/B labelling may not make sense in other languages. With that being said, I don't really have any good alternatives but don't want to commit something before we get more of a consensus.

What about using "Source" and "Target"?

I've been using Gitlabs compare revisions a lot - and I know the context and UI is different, but I feel like maybe the same label be adapted?

E.g left column = "Source", right column = "Target"

"Source" and "Target" then with something to explain it in the help text link:

"When comparing selected revisions the changes are shown as if the source revision was being updated to the target revision."

I have a few clients who often use this screen, I can ask them to review options if we can get a few other ideas in the mix.

@ericgsmith source and target definitely make more sense to me. I'd be happy with that.

Perhaps it should be "Compare" instead of "Select" to make it clear that these are used for comparisons. I have rebased and updated the labels along these lines.

For other languages, these are translatable strings, so it could be whatever is desired in that language.

See MR comments.

Rebased. All comment threads resolved.

Sorry should've mentioned this needs to go into 2.x.

Rebased

Hi @liam morland,

I have replicated the issue and applied the patch you provided, confirmed the issue is solved, however, would it be possible to display the radio buttons at the center of the column. Please see images for reference.

Thanks,
Jake

The uncentered radio buttons

Working on it.

Please review it once.

Thanks for the patch.

Those CSS selectors work to center the radio buttons, but they will change other tables too. It is probably needed to add .diff-responsive-table to the selectors.

NW for #40.

Updated css file but i did not find .diff-responsive-table class in table instead it is .diff-revisions.

Hello @sandip poddar,

Thank you for your contribution to resolving the issue. After applying your changes locally and testing the implementation, I found that the issue is not fully resolved as expected.

I have attached before and after screenshots for your reference, which highlight the areas where the issue persists or behaves unexpectedly. Based on this, I have moved the issue to the "Needs Work" state.

Please review the feedback and the screenshots to make the necessary adjustments. Let me know if you need further clarification or if you'd like to discuss any of the observations.

I am looking into it.

The issue was caused by an inline display: block; style applied to the radio button input. I have resolved this by adjusting the styling accordingly. Please review the changes and let me know if any further modifications are needed.

Hello @sandip poddar,

Thank you for your contribution to resolving the issue. After applying your changes locally and testing the implementation, I found that the issue is working as expected. So I am moving it into RTBC.

Thanks all, this is looking great

Would you cherry-pick this onto 8.x-1.x? It applies cleanly.

@liam morland I'm more inclined to mark 8.x-1.x unsupported but I want to get a stable 2.x release out first. I don't see any reason to use 8.x-1.x anymore.

It would be wonderful if this fix were cherry-picked and a final 8.x-1.9 release made with that and the commits already made. We're on 8.x-1.x until there is a full release of 2.x.

Patch ported to 8.x-1.x for Composer patching.

Done https://www.drupal.org/project/diff/releases/8.x-1.9 →