What branch should I use for Drupal 10?

Thanks @super_romeo, you're right, we have to update the module page description! 2.x is for Drupal 10, sorry

Thank you!

But before reCAPTCHA issue not fixed Change CAPTCHA from ^1.4 to ^1.4 || ^2 in composer.json file ✨ Change CAPTCHA from ^1.4 to ^1.4 || ^2 in composer.json file Fixed there is conflict in composer if require branch 2.x.

That's true, but we can't do anything about it. Please contact the recaptcha maintainers, if needed.

@Anybody, back when we refactored and added quite a bit of code for captcha, we also wanted to change the module page description, but we did not have the permissions to change it, so we kept it. I think I also contacted @wundo about it, but I am not 100% sure.

Anyway, I don't have the permissions to change it. Maybe you @Anybody? But I think not.

Yes I'm now able to change it. Sorry I thought you were also given that permission. I'll fix the text. Thanks @Grevil!

Captcha and recaptcha Drupal 10 requirements are not self-conststent.
[~/www]# composer require 'drupal/captcha:^1.10'
./composer.json has been updated
Running composer update drupal/captcha
Loading composer repositories with package information
Updating dependencies
Your requirements could not be resolved to an installable set of packages.

Problem 1
- Root composer.json requires drupal/captcha ^1.10 -> satisfiable by drupal/captcha[1.10.0, 1.x-dev].
- drupal/captcha[1.10.0, ..., 1.x-dev] require drupal/core ^8.9 || ^9 -> found drupal/core[8.9.0-beta1, ..., 8.9.x-dev, 9.0.0-alpha1, ..., 9.5.x-dev] but the package is fixed to 10.0.7 (lock file version) by a partial update and that version does not match. Make sure you list it as an argument for the update command.
Problem 2
- drupal/captcha[1.10.0, ..., 1.x-dev] require drupal/core ^8.9 || ^9 -> found drupal/core[8.9.0-beta1, ..., 8.9.x-dev, 9.0.0-alpha1, ..., 9.5.x-dev] but the package is fixed to 10.0.7 (lock file version) by a partial update and that version does not match. Make sure you list it as an argument for the update command.
- drupal/recaptcha 3.1.0 requires drupal/captcha ^1.4 -> satisfiable by drupal/captcha[1.10.0, 1.x-dev].
- drupal/recaptcha is locked to version 3.1.0 and an update of this package was not requested.

Use the option --with-all-dependencies (-W) to allow upgrades, downgrades and removals for packages currently locked to specific versions.

Installation failed, reverting ./composer.json and ./composer.lock to their original content.

Captcha 2.x is currently in a beta state. Try running "composer require drupal/captcha:^2" and make sure you have "minimum-stability" set to "beta".

I'm in latest Drupal 10 and site reports incompatible CAPTCHA, but there's no upgrade path. What's the procedure here? Should CAPTCHA 8.x be uninstalled first? I also don't recall seeing a "minimum-stability" option.

Please advise - thanks!

I have minimum-stability set to dev, and still get
/www]# composer require drupal/captcha:^2
./composer.json has been updated
Running composer update drupal/captcha
Loading composer repositories with package information
Updating dependencies
Your requirements could not be resolved to an installable set of packages.

Problem 1
- Root composer.json requires drupal/captcha ^2, found drupal/captcha[dev-2.x, 2.0.0-alpha0, 2.0.0-beta1, 2.x-dev] but these were not loaded, likely because it conflicts with another require.
Problem 2
- drupal/recaptcha is locked to version 3.1.0 and an update of this package was not requested.
- drupal/recaptcha 3.1.0 requires drupal/captcha ^1.4 -> found drupal/captcha[dev-1.x, 1.4.0, ..., 1.x-dev (alias of dev-1.x)] but it conflicts with your root composer.json require (^2).

[~/www]# composer prohibits drupal/captcha "^2"
Info from https://repo.packagist.org: #StandWithUkraine
drupal/recommended-project - requires drupal/captcha (^1.8)
drupal/recaptcha 3.1.0 requires drupal/captcha (^1.4)

Use the option --with-all-dependencies (-W) to allow upgrades, downgrades and removals for packages currently locked to specific versions.

Installation failed, reverting ./composer.json and ./composer.lock to their original content.

Why is this marked as "fixed?" If so, what's the solution? I'm now delaying a deploy of a D10 site until this is resolved, so any guidance is much appreciated! Thanks...

@bcobin: It's not an issue with CAPTCHA but with recaptcha.

See your lines:
- drupal/recaptcha 3.1.0 requires drupal/captcha ^1.4 -> found drupal/captcha[dev-1.x, 1.4.0, ..., 1.x-dev (alias of dev-1.x)] but it conflicts with your root composer.json require (^2).

and the issue linked above from recaptcha:
✨ Change CAPTCHA from ^1.4 to ^1.4 || ^2 in composer.json file Fixed

Thanks for the quick response, @anybody. I upgraded reCaptcha and site still reports the below. This is only after core upgrade to 10.0.7.

There is no upgrade path from 8.x-1.9 and 8.x-1.10 is not Drupal 10 compatible. So back to my original question: what to do here? Thanks...

------

Update Page

Not compatible
Name Installed version Recommended version
CAPTCHA 8.x-1.9 8.x-1.10 (Release notes)
Requires Drupal core:

Question: Why is 8.x-1.10 not compatible with D10 but 8.x-1.9 was. I'm waiting on a few other modules to update their requirements and stuck on 8.x-1.9 for Drupal 10.

@catapipper, see release notes of 8.x-1.10: https://www.drupal.org/project/captcha/releases →

>Removed unwanted Drupal 10 compatibility from 8.x-1.x 🐛 Image not shown, PHP error Closed: duplicate

But as already said, 2.x IS Drupal 10 ready.

Oh I completely missed that, lol. Thanks for setting me straight. Now to wait for Webform to update, allowing 2.x. Issue already added over there.

Glad I could help!

I'm struggling to understand something and may be missing the obvious, but:

If the 2.0 branch of this module is D10 only, and the previous 8.x-1.x version is D8 and D9 only.... how is someone supposed to update this project *prior* to, and in preparation for, updating core to D10? Most other modules are creating branches/releases that support *both* D9 and D10, no?

@komienic

You are right. Therefor, I never updated to version 1.10 and stayed at 1.09 because this version was drupal 9 and 10 compatible. I then moved to te 2.0 version with "composer require drupal/captha..." and not "composer update...".
My opion then was that the 1.10 version was rather a downgrade than an upgrade because they removed the D10 compatibility. This was IMHO not a good solution for another bug. The bug should have been resolved and not by removing the compatibility.
So you should do the jump from 1.09 to 2.x.

@EricVL, @komlenic, the Symfony version changed in Drupal 10, which implemented return type hinting for a bunch of symfony methods. Because our overwritten method did not implement type hinting, the error occurred.

To make sure the module was still Drupal 8.9 compatible, we could NOT simply add the return type hint, as the minimal Drupal 8.9 PHP version is PHP 7.3, which does NOT support return type hinting.

So the question was, to either drop the Drupal 8.9 support or drop the Drupal 10 support. And as we already have a D10 ONLY version with 2.x, the answer was simple.

Not a "bug" we could have simply fixed.

@EricVL: BTW this is open source and there are many things to improve im CAPTCHA for sure! Simply invest money or time to help, it's for your own benefit ;)

@Grevil
Thank you very much for the clear explanation why the 1.10 doesn't support D10 anymore.
This was a logical move to do but I understand the issue from @komlenic too.
@Anybody
I know this is open source and everybody is glad to use it.
I spend allready a lot of time to help people and make things easier for everyone.
My comment was not ment to blame someone. I do apologize if you thought so.
Greetings

Automatically closed - issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.