Add GA4 snippet support in cookies_ga

I'm experiencing the same problem. Updated to 4.0.2 version of the google_analytics module and now the consent is not working anymore. Cookies are set without consent.

This is a blocker because under GDPR we have to stop collecting stats for the moment. As the legacy GA service are shutting down end of the month only few days are left.

Is anybody able to fix this submodule? Thanks!

We can also confirm this behaviour. It's indeed a big issue under GDPR.

We were able to work around this by using cookies_gtag in combination with (COOKiES Google Tag Manager Consent)[ https://www.drupal.org/sandbox/gresko8/3267405] → (sandbox module). That allowed us to use Google Consent Mode through Tag Manager. Altough it's a sandbox module, it works perfectly for what we needed.

Maybe Cookies should look into only supporting google_tag 2.x for Cookies, as this is the recommended module for Google Analytics from now on... Maybe in combination with datalayer/consent mode support...

Thanks guys, happy to review a MR. But we have to make sure it doesn't break old GA.
Best would be to have tests to ensure both works, but that shouldn't be a blocker. I see the importance, but won't have the time to work on this myself.

We'll try to work on this soon, as we need to support this on multiple projects. As soon as we have something working we'll create an MR 👍

Just to clarify the link in #4 should be:

https://www.drupal.org/sandbox/gresko8/3267405 →

Downloading and testing now - many thanks.

/Al

@alexharries, woops, thanks for spotting that - I've updated my comment.

Thanks guys for the update on this issue.

In the meantime I tried cookies_gtag but I get the same problem: cookies for google tag manager are set without consent. Also tried this in conjunction with the sandbox module but no luck.

What a mess with google analytics and tag manager. Not blaming you guys, i really like COOKies. I have to inform my client that with this approach, statistics with google is just not working right now. I'm also running domain access which makes this somehow double hard.

Hopefully @tijsdeboeck can fix a least cookies_ga.

Any community plans here to prepare a MR? The maintainers are very busy currently, so that would speed things up a lot.

Seems like the sandbox module is currently preferred. 😅

I'll dig into it.

Might already work, might not, I'll finish this tomorrow and adjust the tests accordingly (if needed).

2 failing tests, code looks promising so far! :)

Alright, all done!

Tests are green locally and everything works as expected! Please review! 😊

Nice @Grevil! I left final comments.

Alright, adjusted once again, please see my comment!

Nice! Let's merge this into dev for easier testing!

@tijsdeboeck & @VISIOS could you please try the latest 1.2.x-dev version and report, if it fixes the issues?
If yes, we'll tag a new stable release!

Automatically closed - issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.