- Issue created by @rkoller
- Status changed to Active
7 months ago 4:12pm 15 May 2024 - 🇩🇪Germany rkoller Nürnberg, Germany
According to @drumm this issue doesn't have to be postponed anymore since d.o has project browsing now.
- 🇺🇸United States drumm NY, US
The top 200 searches from Google Analytics data are:
565 ckeditor 536 commerce 515 webform 373 views 297 menu 286 admin toolbar 280 slider 252 token 248 taxonomy 235 "lazy load" 234 calendar 227 entity 214 pathauto 212 devel 192 ckeditor5 188 view 179 layout builder 174 paragraphs 173 bootstrap 170 migrate 161 rules 160 captcha 154 smtp 150 comment 142 gallery 127 pdf 127 paragraph 126 field 125 image 124 form 123 profile 122 layout 120 carousel 115 address 112 ctools 111 webp 111 seo 111 chat 110 backup 109 admin 108 search 105 entity reference 103 php 102 slick 102 feeds 102 breadcrumb 101 workflow 99 date 98 media 98 google 97 slideshow 96 css 94 video 94 color 93 redirect 92 metatag 90 user 89 taxonomy manager 89 ai 88 popup 83 taxonomy menu 82 mail 81 inline_entity_form 81 group 81 book 81 blog 80 chatbot 78 google analytics 78 editor 76 language 74 wysiwyg 74 filter 74 cookie 73 import 73 imce 73 drush 71 toolbar 71 recaptcha 70 reference 69 twig 68 button 68 api 67 entity_reference_revisions 66 h5p 65 map 65 forum 64 search api 64 openai 63 sitemap 63 poll 63 lms 63 file 63 colorbox 62 ldap 62 field group 62 event 61 table 61 scheduler 61 path 61 password 60 timeline 60 panels 59 drupal commerce 58 node 58 link 58 backup and migrate 58 back to top 57 youtube 57 jquery 56 theme 56 json 56 icon 55 jquery_ui 55 cache 54 select 54 rest 53 shop 53 gutenberg 53 export 52 quiz 52 clone 52 cart 51 ckeditor 5 50 newsletter 50 modal 50 context 49 composer 49 audio 48 optimize images 48 dashboard 48 content access 48 ajax 47 qr code 47 libraries 47 facebook 47 dns-prefetch 47 booking 46 upload 46 tree 45 taxonomy unique 45 facets 44 wordpress 44 views ui 44 linkit 44 fields 43 superfish 43 share 42 ubercart 41 views slideshow 41 opigno 41 events 40 user permissions 40 stripe 40 social 40 gin 39 title 39 smart date 39 glossary 39 database 39 accordion 38 print 38 login 38 block 38 admin_menu 37 slide 37 field_group 37 charts 37 background 36 signup 36 oauth 36 hero 36 crm 36 config 36 accessibility 35 wiki 35 whatsapp 35 email 35 builder 34 simplenews 34 registration 34 memcache 34 ecommerce 34 chaos tools 34 asset injector 33 vote 33 style 33 mercury 33 chart 32 page manager 32 news 32 leaflet 32 flag 32 banner 31 views data export 31 contextual filters 30 twitter 30 survey 30 qr 30 ecwid 30 custom blockThere is definitely a long tail, there were 8,719 unique queries.
- 🇩🇪Germany rkoller Nürnberg, Germany
thank you for the list! just for the context, what period of time these queries cover? are those the top queries the last week or the last month? and searches from google analytics data, does that mean the searches on google, or searches directly on d.o just tracked with google analytics?
- 🇺🇸United States drumm NY, US
Last 28 days, Google Analytics data of what people search for directly on https://www.drupal.org/project/project_module →
- 🇩🇪Germany rkoller Nürnberg, Germany
Thanks for the clarification! and one thought i've raised over on slack but wanted to document in here per request by @drumm. would it be make sense and be possible to get the search strings only when
works withis set to eitherany,drupal 11,drupal 10,drupal 9, ordrupal 8. and to exclude searches targeting drupal 4-7. those wouldnt have any relevance for project browser anymore? - 🇺🇸United States leslieg
The "Most Relevant" sort criteria should not be an option if there are no Search terms entered, THe results displayed currently are:
If Search terms are present it seems to make sence that Most Relevant become the default sort option
- 🇺🇸United States drumm NY, US
would it be make sense and be possible to get the search strings only when works with is set to either any, drupal 11, drupal 10, drupal 9 , or drupal 8. and to exclude searches targeting drupal 4-7. those wouldnt have any relevance for project browser anymore?
I haven't had a chance to get this filtering done. I’m hesitant to post the raw data since people don’t expect their searches to be made public, and there could be some unique searches in the long tail. And I think people are likely searching for the same things across versions, we’re still making websites and Drupal’s vocabulary isn’t changing too quickly. And searches for older versions will have already fallen off, sites under active development are on newer versions.
The "Most Relevant" sort criteria should not be an option if there are no Search terms entered, THe results displayed currently are:
I think the sort from Drupal.org should always be “relevance”, or something like that. Number of installs should always be a factor in ranking. We may add other factors that are always included, like
- Development status = no further development → negative boost
- Has a version compatible with the latest version of Drupal → positive boost
So there may be no purely sorting by popularity in the future.
Text searches should consider all of that in weighting, but with the text matches on project title, name, description as the most important ranking factor.
- First commit to issue fork.
- 🇪🇸Spain fjgarlin
Related issue. I ran some tests connecting Project Browser to my local, which uses the code on that other issue, and the default results seem to be scored by active installs. I'm going to deploy the changes on that issue to see if there is an impact.
- 🇩🇪Germany rkoller Nürnberg, Germany
would it be possible to get a recent top 100 queries list for the last month or even spanning across a longer interval so that we can then create the list of expected results? (or should be go with the list in #3)?
- 🇺🇸United States drumm NY, US
Go with the list in #3, the search queries likely aren’t changing that often.